The D line ranks 2nd out of the 19 subway lines rated by the Straphangers Campaign. Its line rating markedly improved from 85¢ in our 2000 report to $1.20 this year. Our ranking is based on the MTA New York City Transit data below.
The D line is scheduled to come about as often as the average line...

scheduled minutes between weekday trains
as of January 2000


but arrives with better-than-average regularity.

% of trains arriving at regular intervals
(without gaps in service or train "bunching")
between 6 am and 9 pm


The D breaks down much less often than average.

average miles traveled between delays caused by mechanical failures, July to December 2000

You're more likely to get a seat on the D.

% of passengers with seats at most crowded point during rush hour


The D is tied for the cleanest line...

% of cars with "light or no interior dirtiness"
(as defined by NYC transit)


but performs both above and below average on in-car announcements.

% of trains with correct announcements (as defined by NYC transit)


The NYPIRG Straphangers Campaign line ratings are based on a formula that gives the most weight to the amount of scheduled service, followed by other performance measures. Under this formula, a line would be rated $1.50 if on average its 2000 scores for the measurements above matched a baseline standard defined by the 1996 scores released in our first State of the Subways report. This year, the highest line rating goes to the Q, which scored $1.25. The worst line is the C, at 65¢.

Suggestions? Complaints? Call the D line superintendent at (718) 430-8294.

www.straphangers.org | line rating index | state of the subways report card 2001


Do you agree or disagree
with this line rating?
Agree Disagree
Comments: